Why Taylor Swift's Ring Proves the Old Mine Cut is the New "It" Diamond

Old Mine cut diamond ring shown in close-up view and romantic moment of couple

When Taylor Swift’s engagement ring made headlines, it was not just the size or sparkle that caught attention. It was the fact that her ring featured an Old Mine cut diamond, a choice that feels both historical and fresh. If you are someone who follows celebrity jewelry or you are searching for inspiration for your own ring, this moment proves that vintage designs are making a strong return.

At Van Drake Jewelers in West St Paul, MN, you can see how this traditional cut is stepping back into the spotlight and why it might be the perfect choice for your engagement ring.



Old Mine cut diamond shown in closeup view

What is an Old Mine Cut Diamond?

An Old Mine cut diamond dates back to the 1700s and 1800s. It was hand cut, meaning every diamond is slightly different. Jewelers worked with candlelight in mind, giving these diamonds a softer glow rather than the intense brilliance of modern cuts.

You will notice:

  • A cushion-like shape, square with rounded edges

  • A smaller table (the flat surface on the top)

  • Large facets that create a romantic sparkle

  • A higher crown and deeper pavilion than modern stones

When you look at one, it feels like you are looking into history. That is part of the magic.


Closeup of sparkling diamonds with perfect cut and clarity

Vintage Diamond Cuts vs Modern Brilliance

You might be wondering how this compares to today’s diamonds. Modern brilliant cut diamonds are designed for maximum sparkle under any light. They are symmetrical and polished with exacting detail.

But vintage diamond cuts like the Old Mine offer something different. They do not just shine; they glow. It is a softer, warmer light that feels romantic. Think candlelight dinners rather than floodlit arenas. Both have their place, and the choice depends on your style.

If you want to read more about the differences, visit our Diamond Education page.


Old European Cut vs Old Mine Cut

The Old European cut followed the Old Mine cut in history. While both are antique style diamonds, the Old European is rounder and was the stepping stone toward the modern round brilliant cut.

  • Old Mine cut: Cushion shape, soft sparkle, often in yellow or rose gold settings.

  • Old European cut: Round shape, more symmetrical, often whiter in color.

Both carry romance, but if you want something cushion-shaped with a unique personality, the Old Mine cut may speak to you.


Cushion Cut vs Old Mine Cut

The cushion cut you see today is the modern cousin of the Old Mine. Both are squarish with rounded corners, but cushion cuts are machine cut and highly standardized.

  • Cushion cut: Modern, symmetrical, consistent brilliance.

  • Old Mine cut: Antique, hand cut, each one unique.

Choosing between them is like deciding between a polished movie remake and the original classic film. Both are worth watching, but one carries a certain nostalgia.

 

Close-up of couple's hands with Old Mine cut diamond ring

Why Taylor Swift’s Ring Matters

When a celebrity like Taylor Swift wears an Old Mine cut, it tells you that history has a place in modern style. This is not about following trends blindly—it is about recognizing the charm in something timeless.

For you, it means you have options. You can choose a diamond that is not only beautiful but also a conversation starter. A ring that reflects your personality as much as your love story.


How to Buy a Vintage Diamond

If you are considering this path, here are a few points to keep in mind:

  1. Examine the cut closely – Expect asymmetry; it adds character.

  2. Check the setting – Antique cuts pair beautifully with yellow gold or platinum.

  3. Consider carat weight carefully – Old Mine cuts look larger face-up than modern diamonds of the same weight.

  4. Work with a trusted jeweler – A professional can guide you through the differences and help you compare styles.

At Van Drake Jewelers, you can view a variety of rings and speak with experts who understand both antique and modern cuts.


Should You Consider One?

If you love the idea of:

  • Owning something with character

  • Choosing a diamond that feels different from what everyone else wears

  • Having a ring that blends history with modern style

Then an Old Mine cut might be the right path for you.

And remember, you do not have to be a pop star to enjoy this style. With guidance from the professionals at Van Drake Jewelers, you can find one that fits your taste, budget, and lifestyle.

 

Frequently Asked Questions

1. What is a brilliant cut diamond?
 A brilliant cut diamond is designed with many facets for maximum sparkle. It is the modern standard for brilliance and symmetry.

2 What is the main difference between Old Mine and Old European cuts?
 The Old Mine cut is cushion shaped with a softer glow, while the Old European cut is rounder and more symmetrical.

3. Do Old Mine cut diamonds cost more?
 Not always. Prices vary depending on carat weight, clarity, and demand. Some collectors seek them out, while others focus on modern cuts.

4 Are antique style diamonds durable enough for daily wear?
 Yes, diamonds are still the hardest gemstone. However, older settings may need adjustments or reinforcement from a jeweler.

5. Where can I see Old Mine cut diamonds in person?
Visit Van Drake Jewelers in West St Paul, MN for professional advice and an opportunity to compare styles in person.

Back to Jewelry Blogs